Starting July 2026, we are now requiring appointments for dropping off any material being brought in for trade credit or possible cash purchase.
This new system replaces our previous waiting list. We will no longer be scheduling quarterly trade-in hiatuses.

Please call the store for additional information and to schedule a drop-off appointment. Donations without needing credit do not require an appointment.

Plush Toys & Puppets

Plush Toys & Puppets

  • Robin Finger Puppet front cover

    Robin Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $8.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $8.99
  • Dog Finger Puppet front cover

    Dog Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $12.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $12.99
  • Blue Tarantula Hand Puppet front cover

    Blue Tarantula Hand Puppet

    Firefly Price $32.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $32.99
  • Ragdoll Cat Hand Puppet front cover

    Ragdoll Cat Hand Puppet

    Firefly Price $75.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $75.99
  • Tiny T. Rex and Pointy Plush Pair, 12.5-inches front cover by Jonathan Stutzman and Jay Fleck, ISBN: 1579825478

    Tiny T. Rex and Pointy Plush Pair, 12.5-inches

    Firefly Price $36.00
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $36.00
  • Orange Tabby Kitten Hand Puppet front cover

    Orange Tabby Kitten Hand Puppet

    Firefly Price $24.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $24.99
  • Tiny T. Rex Plush Toy Dinosaur front cover, ISBN: 157982479X

    Tiny T. Rex Plush Toy Dinosaur

    Firefly Price $22.00
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $22.00
  • Owl - Barn Finger Puppet front cover

    Owl - Barn Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $11.49
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $11.49
  • Raven Finger Puppet front cover

    Raven Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $10.49
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $10.49
  • Frog Finger Puppet front cover

    Frog Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $9.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $9.99
  • Rattlesnake Finger Puppet front cover

    Rattlesnake Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $10.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $10.99
  • Funny Bird Hand Puppet front cover

    Funny Bird Hand Puppet

    Firefly Price $46.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $46.99
  • Chipmunk Hand Puppet front cover

    Chipmunk Hand Puppet

    Firefly Price $28.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $28.99
  • Dragon Wristlet Puppet front cover

    Dragon Wristlet Puppet

    Firefly Price $23.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $23.99
  • Chameleon Puppet front cover

    Chameleon Puppet

    Firefly Price $40.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $40.99
  • Dog Finger Puppet front cover

    Dog Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $12.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $12.99
  • Timber Wolf Hand Puppet front cover

    Timber Wolf Hand Puppet

    Firefly Price $43.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $43.99
  • Pearl Dragon Wristlet Finger Puppet front cover

    Pearl Dragon Wristlet Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $20.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $20.99
  • Bunny: Jack Rabbit Finger Puppet front cover

    Bunny: Jack Rabbit Finger Puppet

    Firefly Price $11.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $11.99
  • Axolotl Puppet front cover

    Axolotl Puppet

    Firefly Price $17.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $17.99