Starting July 2026, we are now requiring appointments for dropping off any material being brought in for trade credit or possible cash purchase.
This new system replaces our previous waiting list. We will no longer be scheduling quarterly trade-in hiatuses.

Please call the store for additional information and to schedule a drop-off appointment. Donations without needing credit do not require an appointment.

Amish

Amish

  • A Dream of Miracles front cover by Ruth Reid, ISBN: 1404119280

    A Dream of Miracles [438747]

    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $8.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Front and back covers have light edge and corner wear. Spine intact with no creasing or warping. Binding is tight and intact, pages...
    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $8.50
  • A Hope for Hannah 2 Hannah's Heart front cover by Jerry S. Eicher, ISBN: 0736930442

    A Hope for Hannah 2 Hannah's Heart [430107]

    Retail Price $11.99
    Firefly Price $5.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $11.99
    Firefly Price $5.99
  • Wanted 2 Sisters of the Heart front cover by Shelley Shepard Gray, ISBN: 0061474460

    Wanted 2 Sisters of the Heart [429423]

    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.50
  • The Revealing 3 The Inn at Eagle Hill front cover by Suzanne Woods Fisher, ISBN: 0800720954

    The Revealing 3 The Inn at Eagle Hill [429422]

    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50
  • The Celebration 3 Amish Cooking Class  front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1624167462

    The Celebration 3 Amish Cooking Class [427835]

    Retail Price $15.99
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images...
    Retail Price $15.99
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • The Seekers 1 Amish Cooking Class front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1624167446

    The Seekers 1 Amish Cooking Class [427834]

    Retail Price $15.99
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images...
    Retail Price $15.99
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • The Celebration 3 Amish Cooking Class front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1636092454

    The Celebration 3 Amish Cooking Class [427826]

    Retail Price $7.99
    Firefly Price $3.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images...
    Retail Price $7.99
    Firefly Price $3.99
  • The Blessing 2 Amish Cooking Class front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1636091245

    The Blessing 2 Amish Cooking Class [427825]

    Retail Price $7.99
    Firefly Price $3.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images...
    Retail Price $7.99
    Firefly Price $3.99
  • Written in Love (An Amish Letters Novel) front cover by Kathleen Fuller, ISBN: 0310359929

    Written in Love (An Amish Letters Novel) [426059]

    Retail Price $7.99
    Firefly Price $3.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $7.99
    Firefly Price $3.50
  • On Her Own 2 Brides of Webster County front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1597896101

    On Her Own 2 Brides of Webster County [424371]

    Retail Price $12.95
    Firefly Price $6.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images...
    Retail Price $12.95
    Firefly Price $6.50
  • A Cousin's Prayer 2 Indiana Cousins front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1624162258

    A Cousin's Prayer 2 Indiana Cousins [424368]

    Retail Price $9.99
    Firefly Price $4.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $9.99
    Firefly Price $4.99
  • Hannah's Dream front cover by Jerry Eicher, ISBN: 0978798732

    Hannah's Dream [422759]

    Retail Price $9.99
    Firefly Price $4.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images...
    Retail Price $9.99
    Firefly Price $4.99
  • Miriam's Secret 1 Land of Promise front cover by Jerry S. Eicher, ISBN: 0736958797

    Miriam's Secret 1 Land of Promise [419660]

    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • The Harvest of Grace 3 Ada's House front cover by Cindy Woodsmall, ISBN: 1400073987

    The Harvest of Grace 3 Ada's House [419652]

    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Beloved Hope 2 Heart of the Frontier front cover by Tracie Peterson, ISBN: 0764213288

    Beloved Hope 2 Heart of the Frontier [419646]

    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • Treasured Grace 1 Heart of the Frontier front cover by Tracie Peterson, ISBN: 076421327X

    Treasured Grace 1 Heart of the Frontier [419645]

    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images...
    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • The Devoted 3 The Bishop's Family front cover by Suzanne Woods Fisher, ISBN: 0800723228

    The Devoted 3 The Bishop's Family [419640]

    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • The Quieting 2 Bishop's Family front cover by Suzanne Woods Fisher, ISBN: 080072321X

    The Quieting 2 Bishop's Family [419639]

    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50
  • Rosemary Opens Her Heart (Home at Cedar Creek) front cover by Naomi King, ISBN: 0451237978

    Rosemary Opens Her Heart (Home at Cedar Creek) [417718]

    Retail Price $14.00
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of...
    Retail Price $14.00
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Lydia's Charm front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1602600635

    Lydia's Charm [413003]

    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Front and back covers have wear to edges and corners. Spine intact, some wear. Binding is intact. Pages are generally clean with edge or...
    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50