Starting July 2026, we are now requiring appointments for dropping off any material being brought in for trade credit or possible cash purchase.
This new system replaces our previous waiting list. We will no longer be scheduling quarterly trade-in hiatuses.

Please call the store for additional information and to schedule a drop-off appointment. Donations without needing credit do not require an appointment.

Puzzles

Puzzles

  • Good Humor Ice Cream 1000 Piece Puzzle [524167]

    Good Humor Ice Cream 1000 Piece Puzzle [524167]

    Firefly Price $9.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Firefly Price $9.99
  • Granny Squares 750 Peice Puzzle [524166]

    Granny Squares 750 Peice Puzzle [524166]

    Firefly Price $8.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Firefly Price $8.99
  • Cupcake 1000 Piece Puzzle + Mini Poster [524165]

    Cupcake 1000 Piece Puzzle + Mini Poster [524165]

    Firefly Price $8.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Firefly Price $8.99
  • Summertime 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [524007]

    Summertime 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [524007]

    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art...
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Gathering of Friends 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [524006]

    Gathering of Friends 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [524006]

    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Forest Dream 500 Piece Round Jigsaw Puzzle

    Forest Dream 500 Piece Round Jigsaw Puzzle

    Firefly Price $24.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this...
    Firefly Price $24.99
  • Moth 500 Piece Round Jigsaw Puzzle

    Moth 500 Piece Round Jigsaw Puzzle

    Firefly Price $24.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this...
    Firefly Price $24.99
  • Moon Garden 1000 Piece Square Jigsaw Puzzle

    Moon Garden 1000 Piece Square Jigsaw Puzzle

    Firefly Price $24.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this...
    Firefly Price $24.99
  • Williamsburg 36 Piece Dissected Puzzle [523001]

    Williamsburg 36 Piece Dissected Puzzle [523001]

    Firefly Price $11.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. This item cannot be shipped as Media Mail and may require additional shipping costs. Cover image may be...
    Firefly Price $11.99
  • Magical Creatures 100 Piece Puzzle

    Magical Creatures 100 Piece Puzzle

    Firefly Price $18.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this...
    Firefly Price $18.99
  • Mushroom Rainbow 1000 Piece Puzzle front cover

    Mushroom Rainbow 1000 Piece Puzzle

    Firefly Price $26.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $26.99
  • Dinosaur Land 20 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle front cover

    Dinosaur Land 20 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle

    Firefly Price $13.99
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Unless otherwise noted, all photos on this page are of the actual product and property of Firefly Bookstore, or are images sourced from the...
    Firefly Price $13.99
  • Christmas Chorus 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle front cover, ISBN: 0735353085

    Christmas Chorus 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [522545]

    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Dream Big 300 Large Piece Puzzle [522310]

    Dream Big 300 Large Piece Puzzle [522310]

    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. This item cannot be shipped as Media Mail and may require additional shipping costs. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from...
    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Tides of Madness Game [522293]

    Tides of Madness Game [522293]

    Retail Price $18.00
    Firefly Price $8.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. This item cannot be shipped as Media Mail and may require additional shipping costs. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be...
    Retail Price $18.00
    Firefly Price $8.99
  • Home Sweet Home 300 Piece Puzzle [522094]

    Home Sweet Home 300 Piece Puzzle [522094]

    Firefly Price $5.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Firefly Price $5.99